Hundreds pack gym to oppose Malheur County monument proposal
Capital Press
ADRIAN, Ore. — Ranchers, farmers and other Malheur County residents packed Adrian High School’s gymnasium Oct. 29 to oppose a proposal that would designate 2.5 million acres of the county as a national conservation or wilderness area.
The 500-person crowd was mostly against the Owyhee Canyonlands Conservation Proposal but included a contingent of people from other parts of the state who support it.
Loud applause and standing ovations greeted those who spoke against the proposal but mostly silence followed after people who support it spoke.
“We live here and pay taxes here and I’m hoping what we say has a little more weight than what somebody from across the state says,” said Adrian area farmer Brent Ishida.
Ranchers and farmers believe locking up that much land — it would equal 43 percent of the entire county — would devastate ranching, which is the county’s main agricultural commodity and brings in about $130 million in farm-gate receipts annually.
Most ranching operations in southeastern Oregon are tied to federal grazing permits and the proposal would negatively impact that industry, states a Harney County resolution opposing the proposal.
The resolution says the proposal would also cause a “loss of direct jobs and jobs within the supply chain of the agriculture and cattle industries.”
The proposal is backed by the Owyhee Coalition, which includes thousands of people and organizations across the state and country, said Brent Fenty, executive director of the Oregon Natural Desert Association, which is spearheading the effort.
“We all care about the Owyhee and want to keep it the way it is today, we just may disagree on how we do that,” he said. “I sincerely hope the future of the Owyhee is not oil and gas drilling.”
Fenty said livestock grazing and mining activities would be grandfathered into any monument or wilderness designation and allowed to continue where it’s occurring now.
But opponents doubted that and Jordan Valley rancher Bob Skinner, who is leading the opposition effort, received a standing ovation when he told the crowd, “Don’t believe that stuff. The proponents of this (proposal) are professional litigators. Once this gets to court, all bets are off.”
Many proposal supporters said it would result in a lot of tourism dollars from the nation’s large outdoor industry but locals weren’t convinced. Opponents also expressed doubt that the federal government could care for the place better than their families have for generations.
The meeting, which was organized by Rep. Cliff Bentz, R-Ontario, was videotaped and will be shown on the internet and presented to President Barack Obama, Bentz said.
He said opponents are concerned the president may act on the proposal without being aware of how much local opposition there is to it.
Commissioners and judges from five other Eastern Oregon counties and Owyhee County, Idaho, were at the meeting and spoke against the proposal.
“We will continue to stand with each other in Eastern Oregon and protect our home,” said Grant County Court Judge Scott Myers.